Elliptical Vs Stairmaster 2026: Which is Better?

Last update:

*HomeGymUnlimited helps consumers find the best home fitness products. When you buy a product we recommend, we may earn a commission.

Updated October 2026: we checked every machine again and replaced the ones that are no longer available.

The elliptical and the stairmaster both give you a low-impact cardio workout. But they differ in how they work your muscles, how many calories they burn, and how they feel on your joints.

YouTube

This content is blocked because YouTube cookies have not been accepted.

As a personal trainer, I help my clients choose between these two machines. Below I compare them on seven points, and then I recommend the machines I would look at for a home gym.

My short answer: if you have the budget and the space, get both. If you can only choose one, I prefer the elliptical. You work slightly more muscles with it, and it is a bit kinder to your knees. And you can always do the stairmaster workout on a regular staircase.

Can’t choose? There is also a machine that combines the elliptical and the stair stepper.

Let’s start.

Elliptical Vs Stairmaster Comparison

Type of motion

Elliptical Vs Stairmaster
Elliptical and stairmaster differ in how they engage muscles

Elliptical

An elliptical trainer is a stationary machine that mimics the motion of running without the impact on your joints. You can move forward or backward and change the resistance and, on many machines, the incline.

On a classic elliptical the handles stay in place, so you can hold on for balance. Many ellipticals also have moving handles. Then you work your arms and shoulders too, like on a cross trainer.

Stairmaster

A stairmaster (or stair stepper) mimics climbing stairs. With a high speed and a light resistance you get a high-intensity cardio workout. With a slower speed and a heavy resistance it becomes more of a strength workout for your legs and glutes. On some machines you can also step sideways and train the sides of your legs.

As a personal trainer, I recommend training both running-type and climbing-type movements. With enough budget and space, you could have both machines at home. If not, choose the one that fits your needs best. Consider the points below.

Calories Burned

If you want to burn as many calories as possible per minute, choose the elliptical.

According to Harvard Health Publishing, a 155-pound person burns about 324 calories in 30 minutes on an elliptical trainer. On a stair-step machine it is about 216 calories. That is roughly 50% more on the elliptical.

Winner: Calories Burned
Elliptical, because according to Harvard it burns about 50% more calories in the same time.

Impact on your Joints

In general, the elliptical is easier on your joints than the stairmaster.

An elliptical gives you a low-impact workout, which is why it is a popular choice for people who want to be careful with their joints [1]. On a stair stepper you lift your body weight on every step, so your knees and ankles carry more of the load.

Is the elliptical a safe choice for everyone? No. Whatever machine you choose, you need good technique. And if you have knee, back or hip complaints, always start together with a physiotherapist or personal trainer.

Winner: Impact Level
Elliptical, because it is easier on your joints.

Intensity

If you want to get your heart rate up fast, look at the stairmaster. It is great for short, high-intensity bursts, because climbing stairs takes a lot of effort.

The elliptical lets you build up gradually. It is a good option if you want a workout that is gentle on your joints. But you can make it hard too: choose a high resistance.

Winner: Intensity
Stairmaster, because it gives a more intense workout.

Muscle Toning

An elliptical works your hamstrings, glutes, quadriceps, calves and core. A stairmaster works almost the same muscle groups. With moving handles on the elliptical you also train your arms and shoulders.

The difference is in the feel. The elliptical gives you a smooth, natural stride. A stairmaster makes you lift your own body weight with every step, which is more demanding for your legs and glutes.

My experience as a trainer: with the elliptical you get slightly more muscles involved, especially when you use the moving handles. But on both machines the effect depends on how you train. A relaxed ride with a light resistance gives you much less than a heavy one.

Winner: Muscle Toning
A tie. The stairmaster is more demanding for your legs and glutes, the elliptical involves slightly more muscles in total.

Versatility

On an elliptical you can change the resistance, and often the incline and the stride length. You can move forward and backward. Many ellipticals also work as a cross trainer.

On a stairmaster you can adjust speed and resistance. On some models you can also step sideways, which an elliptical can’t do. That trains different muscles in your legs.

Winner: Versatility
No winner. Just different exercises.

Comfort

The elliptical is simple and easy to use. A stairmaster takes some getting used to. The elliptical is also more comfortable for most people, because it is easier on your joints.

Winner: Comfort
Elliptical, because it is easier to use.

Cost

Stair steppers cover the widest price range: from about $53 for a mini stepper to $1,700 for a full-size climber like the SOLE CC81 below. The ellipticals on this page cost $320 to $380. So for a full-size machine, the elliptical is usually the cheaper choice, while a mini stepper is the cheapest way to start.

Winner: Cost
Elliptical for full-size machines, because it is usually cheaper. A mini stepper is the cheapest way to start.

Elliptical Vs Stairmaster: The Winner

Looking at the points above, the elliptical is the better choice for most people. But your choice depends on your goal and your preference, so take the time to find the right fit.

  • The elliptical burns about 50% more calories in the same time (according to Harvard).
  • The stairmaster is the more intense workout and tones your legs and glutes more directly.
  • The elliptical is easier on your joints and is easy to use.
  • Budget and space: with both, you have the best of both worlds. If not, choose the elliptical, and use a regular staircase for the stair workout.

What I tell my clients

If you have the budget and the space, you could choose both. If not, I prefer the elliptical: you pick up slightly more muscles with it, and it protects your knees a bit better. Climbing stairs you can also do on a regular staircase, at home or at work.

These are the mistakes I see most often, on both machines:

  • Leaning forward and hanging on the handles. Stand tall, so your legs do the work.
  • Going much too fast on a light setting. Especially as you get older, you are better off training heavier: a higher resistance, with controlled movements.
  • Watching TV while you train. You are less focused, and you get less out of your workout.

My favorite way to train on both machines is interval training: 25 seconds fast, or even better heavy, then 1 minute 30 seconds rest. Repeat that 8 to 10 times.

I do my own intervals outdoors when I can: sprinting up a sand dune. In the gym I use the rowing machine. In hotels I often use the elliptical, and I take the regular stairs.

And if you have knee, back or hip complaints: always start together with a physiotherapist or a personal trainer.

As you decide between a stairmaster and an elliptical, here are the machines I would look at.

Elliptical Recommendations

Prices and ratings are from the Amazon listings in October 2026.

Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Upright Elliptical

FeaturesSunny Health & Fitness Smart Upright Elliptical
Stride length12 in
Resistance levels16
Maximum user weight300 lbs
AppSunnyFit (free)
Price$319.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.1★ from 20,058 ratings
Features of Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Upright Elliptical (October 2026)

The Sunny Smart Upright Elliptical is the one I would look at first if you want a simple, affordable elliptical with a lot of reviews. It has a 12-inch stride, 16 resistance levels and a maximum user weight of 300 pounds, and it works with the free SunnyFit app. A 12-inch stride is on the short side, so it suits shorter users best. If you are tall, look at the two ellipticals below.

It replaces the Sunny Essentials Smart Elliptical from our earlier list, which is now a different listing.


ANCHEER Foldable Elliptical

FeaturesANCHEER Foldable Elliptical
Stride length16 in
Maximum user weight550 lbs
FoldableYes
Price$341.97 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.5★ from 1,137 ratings
Features of ANCHEER Foldable Elliptical (October 2026)

The ANCHEER has a long 16-inch stride, a maximum user weight of 550 pounds and it folds up when you don’t use it. That makes it a good choice for taller or heavier users, and for a smaller room.

It replaces the Schwinn 430 from our earlier list, which is no longer available.


Niceday Elliptical Machine

FeaturesNiceday Elliptical Machine
Stride length15.5 in
Maximum user weight400 lbs
Price$379.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.3★ from 3,528 ratings
Features of Niceday Elliptical Machine (October 2026)

The Niceday has a 15.5-inch stride and a maximum user weight of 400 pounds. It has more than 3,500 ratings, which makes it a safe alternative to the ANCHEER if you don’t need a foldable machine.


Elliptical and stair stepper in one

YOSUDA 3-in-1 Elliptical, Stepper and Cardio Climber

FeaturesYOSUDA 3-in-1 Elliptical, Stepper and Cardio Climber
FunctionsElliptical, stair stepper, cardio climber
Incline12° and 45°
Maximum user weight300 lbs
Price$379.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.3★ from 827 ratings
Features of YOSUDA 3-in-1 Elliptical, Stepper and Cardio Climber (October 2026)

If you can’t decide, or you have room for only one machine, the YOSUDA combines an elliptical, a stair stepper and a cardio climber. It has a 12° and a 45° incline setting and a maximum user weight of 300 pounds. A machine that does everything doesn’t do everything as well as a dedicated machine, but it is a practical compromise for a small home gym.

It replaces the Body Power 2-in-1, Body Rider and Body Power 3-in-1 machines from our earlier list, which are no longer available.


Stairmaster Recommendations

Sunny Health & Fitness Mini Stair Stepper

FeaturesSunny Health & Fitness Mini Stair Stepper
TypeMini stepper
Price$52.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.4★ from 36,418 ratings
Features of Sunny Health & Fitness Mini Stair Stepper (October 2026)

The Sunny Mini Stair Stepper is the cheapest way to try stair climbing at home, and it has more than 36,000 ratings. It is small, so it is easy to store. It is a mini stepper, not a full-size climber, so it is best for lighter workouts and for beginners.


Sunny Health & Fitness Foldable Stair Climber

FeaturesSunny Health & Fitness Foldable Stair Climber
Stride length21.5 in
FoldableYes
Price$149.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.1★ from 1,796 ratings
Features of Sunny Health & Fitness Foldable Stair Climber (October 2026)

The Sunny Foldable Stair Climber has a 21.5-inch stride, so it feels like climbing real stairs, and it folds up for storage. If you want more than a mini stepper without paying for a full-size climber, this is the step in between.


Relife Foldable Vertical Climber

FeaturesRelife Foldable Vertical Climber
Resistance levels5
FoldableYes
Price$125.99 (Amazon, October 2026)
Rating4.2★ from 71 ratings
Features of Relife Foldable Vertical Climber (October 2026)

The Relife is a vertical climber with 5 resistance levels that folds up when you are done. It is simple and affordable. It has only 71 ratings so far, so I would treat it as a budget option and check the latest reviews.

It replaces the earlier Relife listing, which is no longer available.


SOLE CC81 Cardio Climber

FeaturesSOLE CC81 Cardio Climber
Resistance levels20
Maximum user weight400 lbs
Frame warrantyLifetime
Price$1,699.99 (Amazon, sold by SOLE Fitness, October 2026)
Rating4.2★ from 26 ratings
Features of SOLE CC81 Cardio Climber (October 2026)

The SOLE CC81 is the full-size option. It has 20 resistance levels, a maximum user weight of 400 pounds and a lifetime frame warranty. At $1,699.99 it is the most expensive machine on this list, and it has only 26 ratings on Amazon. If money is not an issue and you want a climber that feels like a gym machine, this is the one to look at.


FAQ on Elliptical vs Stairmaster

  • Is the StairMaster or elliptical better?

    For a more intense workout and for toning your legs and glutes, choose the stairmaster. For a lower-impact workout, more calories burned and easier use, choose the elliptical. If you have the budget and the space, you can get both. If you can only choose one, I prefer the elliptical.

  • What’s better for weight loss elliptical or StairMaster?

    According to Harvard Health Publishing, a 155-pound person burns about 324 calories in 30 minutes on an elliptical and about 216 on a stair-step machine. So the elliptical burns about 50% more calories in the same time. But the best machine for weight loss is the one you use consistently, and with enough effort.

  • What is the best way to train on an elliptical or stairmaster?

    Interval training works well: 25 seconds fast, or even better heavy, then 1 minute 30 seconds rest, repeated 8 to 10 times. Stand tall instead of leaning forward, and don’t go very fast on a light setting. Training heavier is better, especially as you get older. And don’t watch TV while you train: you will be less focused and get less out of your workout.

  • Is the elliptical or the stairmaster better for knee problems?

    The elliptical is slightly kinder to your knees. But on both machines you need good technique, and if you have knee, back or hip complaints you should always start together with a physiotherapist or personal trainer.

What to do next?

First, think about the goal you want to reach with the elliptical or the stairmaster. Write it down.

Next, read this comparison again and select the points that matter most to you.

Finally, look at the machines I recommended and make your choice. Take your time. The right cardio machine for your home gym can change your training.

Happy Training in your Home Gym!
Inge
Personal Trainer and Nutrition Coach

Related Articles on Ellipticals/Cross trainers:

Photo of author

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Inge van Haselen is a certified Personal Trainer and Nutritional Coach. For over 20 years, she has been coaching hundreds of clients in her gym. Inge published several programs on health and fitness. It is her passion to help you have the best Home Gym for your needs, so you can be in the best shape of your life. More info: About Us